Why Is One Ratchet $5 and Another $80?

You’re standing in the tool aisle. One ratchet is $5. Another is $80. They both say “chrome vanadium,” they both turn bolts, and let’s be honest—you’re wondering if the expensive one is just for people who like showing off.

Spoiler alert: there is a difference. But depending on how you use your tools, it might not be the difference you think.

What Makes a Ratchet Expensive?

Let’s break down where that price tag comes from:

1. Teeth Count

The number of teeth in the ratchet gear determines how far you have to swing the handle to engage the next click.

• Cheap ratchet: 24–36 teeth (big swing needed)
• Premium ratchet: 72–120 teeth (short swing, smooth feel)

If you’re working in tight spaces (like under a dash or in an engine bay), more teeth = more control.

2. Materials and Finish

$5 ratchets use lower-grade metals that might deform under stress.

$80 ratchets often use higher-grade alloys, better heat treatment, and finishes that resist corrosion and feel great in hand.

You’re not just paying for durability—you’re paying for comfort, balance, and longevity.

3. Mechanism and Tolerances

Cheaper ratchets often have looser internals and simpler pawl mechanisms. That means more slop (backlash), less torque tolerance, and a greater chance of stripping out when things get tough. High-end ratchets have tighter tolerances, dual pawls, and sealed mechanisms that keep dirt out and keep the action silky smooth.

4. Warranty and Brand Trust

A cheap ratchet often comes with no warranty—or worse, a “good luck” return policy. The $80 ratchet? Lifetime warranty. Break it, and they’ll replace it. That’s not just customer service—it’s confidence in their product.

But Do You Need the Expensive One?

Not always.

Here’s the rule of thumb:

• If you're an occasional DIYer or only use a ratchet a few times a year, a decent mid-range tool will serve you well.
• If you're turning wrenches every weekend, crawling into engine bays, or working in tight spots—yes, the $80 ratchet earns its keep.
• If you’re fixing something professionally? That $80 ratchet might save you money over time by preventing busted knuckles, stripped bolts, and tool failures mid-job.

The Internet Method Perspective: Buy Tools That Match Your Workflow

Just like troubleshooting requires the right mindset, fixing things requires the right tools. Buying cheap tools for the sake of saving money can lead to frustration, rework, or failure when you need performance most.

My take: Go with the highest tooth count and best material quality ratchet you can afford.

Tools don’t have to be expensive—but they do have to be reliable. A good ratchet isn’t just a luxury. It’s an investment in your sanity

Final Thought: The $5 Ratchet Might Work—Until It Doesn’t

We’ve all been there. You buy the cheap one, it works… for a while. Then one day you’re stuck in a job, bolt half-loose, ratchet locked up, and you’re muttering regrets under your breath.

Spend the money once, or spend it twice. That’s the rule.

Want a guide to the essential tools you should own—without overspending?

Download the free “Basic Tool List” at theinternetmethod.com and start building a kit that won’t let you down.